If coconut oil had a relationship status on Facebook, it would read: “It’s complicated.” One day, it is glorified as the holy grail of health and beauty. The next day, it's cancelled by nutritionists on a live TV debate. If you have whiplash from this back-and-forth, welcome to the club.
So what is the truth? Is coconut oil a saint, a sinner, or simply misunderstood? Let’s unpack the controversies and place them beside facts.
CONTROVERSY #1: “Coconut oil is bad for your heart”
This headline travels like wildfire every few months. The logic behind it goes: coconut oil is high in saturated fats, and saturated fats raise cholesterol. Therefore, coconut oil equals a clogged artery waiting to happen.
THE TRUTH
Not all saturated fats behave the same way in the body. Coconut oil is primarily composed of medium-chain triglycerides (MCTs), such as lauric acid, which are metabolised differently than the long-chain fats found in butter or red meat.
MCTs are digested more quickly, used as a quick source of energy, and research shows they may increase HDL (good cholesterol) and improve the overall lipid profile when consumed in moderation. The keyword is not “avoid,” but “dose.” Two tablespoons a day is the frequently recommended ceiling.
Coconut oil does not deserve the heart-villain costume it is force-fitted into.
CONTROVERSY #2: “It clogs pores and ruins skin”
If you have ever spent time on skincare Reddit, you’ve probably seen dramatic confessions of people who claim coconut oil attacked their face like an ambush.
THE TRUTH
Can coconut oil clog pores? Yes, for some skin types. It is comedogenic on acne-prone or very oily skin. But the story ends there.
For dry, sensitive, eczematous, or barrier-damaged skin, virgin coconut oil is a quiet hero. Its lauric acid offers antimicrobial benefits, it seals moisture, calms inflammation, and supports wound repair. Numerous dermatology studies show improvements in eczema severity when coconut oil is used correctly on damp skin.
CONTROVERSY #3: “Coconut oil makes you gain weight”
Everything edible is now evaluated by one metric: “Will this make me fat?” Naturally, coconut oil is not spared.
THE TRUTH
Weight gain depends on caloric surplus, not a specific food. Coconut oil contains calories like any oil. If you drown your food in it, yes, the scale will respond accordingly.
However, replacing long-chain fats with MCT-rich oils (like virgin coconut oil) can mildly boost metabolism, improve satiety, and has been linked in multiple small studies to supporting fat-burning, particularly abdominal fat, when used mindfully with a calorie-controlled diet.
CONTROVERSY #4: “Coconut oil is overhyped wellness marketing”
With so many influencers bathing in it, cooking with it, oil-pulling with it, massaging babies with it, and removing makeup with it, suspicions of hype are valid.
THE TRUTH
It is not hype if the benefits are evidence-backed and time-tested. Coconut oil has been used for centuries across cultures, and modern research supports many of its historical uses:
- Antimicrobial against bacteria, fungi, and viruses
-
Antioxidant action that protects cells
-
Barrier repair for skin and scalp
-
Therapeutic support in wound healing and eczema
-
Safe, stable cooking oil with a respectable smoke point
-
MCT-mediated metabolic benefits
CONTROVERSY #5: “It is unhealthy because it’s a saturated fat”
Nutrition 101 told us to fear saturated fat like medieval villagers feared dragons.
THE TRUTH
Nutrition science has evolved, and we must evolve with it. Lumping all saturated fats into one danger zone is outdated. The molecular length, source, and metabolic fate of fats matter, and coconut oil’s medium-chain profile behaves nothing like the saturated fat in bacon.
Newer controlled trials show neutral to beneficial cardiovascular impact when coconut oil replaces refined carbohydrates or less healthy fats.
Demonisation without nuance is lazy science.
FINAL VERDICT
Coconut oil is neither a miracle elixir nor a dietary grenade. It is a high-quality natural fat with legitimate, documented benefits, provided it is used in context, moderation, and for the right applications.
So the next time someone dramatically declares, “Coconut oil is terrible for you,” feel free to politely remind them: controversy makes headlines, but truth survives time.
